What a rest of Africa unequivocally thinks about South Africa

South Africa has variously styled itself as a “bridge” between a North, a global South and Africa as good as a “gateway” into a continent. It also sees itself as a orator for Africa, given a membership of a fondness of Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa BRICS and a G20.

It has announced a joining to a continent’s Africa agenda, a African Union’s desirous growth skeleton characterized as “Agenda 2063 – The Africa We Want”.

But how do Africans over South Africa’s borders viewpoint a country? What are a perceptions of a country’s purpose on a continent? Are these aligned with a proceed in that a nation perceives a purpose and change on a continent?

In a new turn of interviews with comparison African Union officials and observers of continental politics in Addis Ababa, headquarters of a African Union, we asked people about their views on South Africa’s African process and actions. The agreement was that a interviews would be dealt with as unattributed quotes. This enabled us to appeal a operation of straightforward opinions and observations to surprise a investigate plan on a doing of South Africa’s “African Agenda”.

We were struck by a fact that a interviewees all lifted identical issues and concerns. What was also distinguished was a border to that these perceptions were during contingency with South Africa’s self-declared purpose on a continent, as good as a impact it believes it’s had in furthering growth and lifting a continent’s general profile.

There’s a remarkable disproportion between how South Africans as people and as a supervision see themselves and how a rest of a continent perceives them. Our discussions in Addis Ababa highlighted a series of repeated themes that made these views.

Failed expectations

Interviewees steadfastly lifted a emanate of xenophobia in South Africa. A clarity of dishonesty and fortitude disbelief pervaded discussions.

Demostrators impetus opposite a new call of xenophobic attacks, in Khayelitsha municipality nearby Cape Town, May 31, 2008. A call of attacks on foreigners in South Africa has killed 62 people given a assault pennyless out 3 weeks ago, military pronounced on Saturday. REUTERS/Mark Wessels (SOUTH AFRICA) - RTX6D95
A betrayal. (Reuters/Mark Wessels)

A series remarkable that after a conflict of assault in 2015 a South African supervision primarily refused to commend that a attacks were opposite foreigners. The problem was compounded when South African domestic leaders explained a xenophobic attacks as rapist acts when it was transparent that they were targeted during non-South Africans.

It finally did respond, though usually after a corner critique of several African ambassadors in Pretoria and rare criticism movement in several African countries.

Several interviewees mentioned that there have also been large-scale attacks on foreigners in 2008.

The views voiced were that attacks opposite foreigners valid that South Africans didn’t viewpoint themselves as partial of a continent. And, as one of a interviewees commented, a supervision had not prepared South Africans to know how many a continent had contributed and sacrificed to finish apartheid:

They (the South Africans) are not unequivocally African—they are their possess Africa.

Double speak

A deeper problem articulated by those we talked to is of a flourishing miss of trust in South Africa’s bona fides. The nation claims to paint a continent in BRICS and a G20. But there’s a clarity that really small advantage accrues to a rest of a continent.

The widespread viewpoint is that South Africa does not use these platforms to emanate or foster opportunities for wider African involvement. Rather, a possess mercantile interests always suffer priority. This, notwithstanding South Africa’s tongue of ubuntu (human kindness) and a African Agenda.

According to some of those we interviewed a trend of compelling a possess interests has turn quite apparent during a epoch of boss Jacob Zuma.

Libyan personality Muammar Gaddafi (2nd R) talks with Congo's President Denis Sassou Nguessou (2nd L) as they mount for sketch with South Africa's President Jacob Zuma (L) and Mauritania's President Mohamed Ould Abdel Aziz outward a tent in Gaddafi's heavily fortified Bab al-Aziziya devalue in Tripoli Apr 10, 2011. Gaddafi, creation his initial coming in front of a unfamiliar media in weeks, assimilated a visiting African Union commission during his Bab al-Aziziyah devalue in Tripoli on Sunday.  REUTERS/Zohra Bensemra   (LIBYA - Tags: CIVIL UNREST POLITICS) - RTR2L2Y4
Gaddafi suspicion South Africa was his friend. (Reuters/Zohra Bensemra)

Related to this was a notice that South Africa behaved in a paradoxical proceed when it came to a African Union (AU) and a UN Security Council. Several interviewees forked out that in 2011 South Africa was opposite involvement in Libya and upheld an African resolution to a crisis. Yet in a Security Council it voted for Resolution 1973 that certified NATO intervention. This led to Muammar Gaddafi being defeated and a successive collapse of a Libyan state that unleashed an epoch of disturbance and instability in a Sahel.

As one interviewee put it:

South Africa has dual platforms for raised power. One is a AU and one is a UN and during times these roles are contradictory.


A third emanate mentioned by all a interviewees was South Africa’s control within a AU, and a border to that it projected a kind of “big brother, large bully” approach.

 South Africa frequently berated other countries, quite smaller Francophone states, for their “colonial mentality”. There is still clever rancour about a proceed South Africa ran a campaign to get Nkosazana Dlamini-Zuma elected as chairperson of a AU. One interviewee explained how South Africa frequently berated other countries, quite smaller Francophone states, for their “colonial mentality”, implying that their support for afterwards presiding chairperson Jean Ping for a second tenure was tied adult with their servility to France.

There was also a clarity of South Africa undermining a continental position on a growth of an African Standby Force. Instead, a nation is insisting that a fast response capability should be grown – a supposed African Capacity for Immediate Response to Crises.

Leading by listening

Of course, from a South African perspective, many of these allegations could be denied and explained by “hard contribution and figures”. During a second term as an inaugurated member of a Security Council from 2011 to 2012, South Africa prioritized African confidence issues.

The nation has invested in compelling assent and fortitude in war-torn countries such as Burundi, South Sudan and a Democratic Republic of a Congo. It’s deliberate by some observers to minister some-more than a UN-required 0.7 per cent of GDP annually to development assist on a continent.

But that’s not a point. In a tactful universe perceptions matter as many as contribution in a plan of process responses and a constraints on success.

The disaster of policymakers to try and know a perceptions of those during a receiving finish of their policies can come during a cost. It can also perplex well-intended policies and even lead to low rancour and tragedy between countries.

It might do South Africans, either typical adults or unfamiliar process officials, good to ask themselves how others see them – and why. And a country’s policymakers would advantage from perplexing to know how their actions are viewed by others.The Conversation

Maxi Schoeman, Professor of International Relations and Deputy Dean: Postgraduate Studies, Faculty of Humanities, University of Pretoria; Asnake Kefale, Assistant Professor, Political Science and International Relations, Addis Ababa University, and Chris Alden, Professor of International Relations, London School of Economics and Political Science.

This essay was creatively published on The Conversation. Read a original article.

Sign adult for a Quartz Africa Weekly Brief — a many critical and engaging news from opposite a continent, in your inbox.

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Widgetized Section

Go to Admin » appearance » Widgets » and move a widget into Advertise Widget Zone