The Problem With Cherie Blair’s Statement About Rape In Africa

Women’s rights romantic Cherie Blair sparked snub final week after The Guardian reported that she pronounced “most African ladies’ initial passionate knowledge is rape” during a harangue on Mar 20.

Blair, who is a founder of a charity that supports womanlike entrepreneurs in building countries and who is married to former U.K. Prime Minister Tony Blair, was giving a speak about women and leadership to a organisation of about 100 students and members of a community, hold during a delegate propagandize in London.

While some people contend that Blair was highlighting a critical problem, many women called her out for perpetuating extremist stereotypes: that African group are aroused and African women are diseased and incompetent to give consent. And some critics pronounced it was not her place, as a absolute white woman, to speak about African issues.

When NPR asked for comment, Blair’s bureau did not respond. But her substructure referred us to Blair’s matter to The Guardian, in that she pronounced her initial acknowledgement was in answer to a doubt about youth African girls blank out on preparation due to resources such as early pregnancy.

“In that context we pronounced that for a immeasurable infancy of immature girls — who are mostly 12-, 13-, 14-year-olds – their initial knowledge of sex was rape,” Blair pronounced in her statement.

The statistic, she told The Guardian, comes from a World Health Organization news from 2002, that pronounced that “A flourishing series of studies, quite from sub-Saharan Africa, prove that a initial passionate knowledge of girls is mostly neglected and forced.”

Other observers, such as Dr. Tlaleng Mofokeng, a medical alloy and longtime passionate and reproductive rights disciple in South Africa, contend a forced initial passionate knowledge is not singular to Africa.

UNICEF estimates that about 120 million girls underneath a age of 20 worldwide have gifted forced passionate retort or other forced passionate acts during some indicate in their lives. That’s roughly 1 in 10 girls globally.

Mofokeng talked to NPR about a debate and how she wishes Blair’s review had gone. “Dr. T,” as Mofokeng calls herself, is an Aspen Institute New Voices associate and a owner of Nalane for Reproductive Justice. Her answers have been edited for length and clarity.

What was your initial greeting when we listened what Blair said?

As a black lady who works in a passionate and reproductive rights space, we was only like, “Oh, typical.”

A lot of black women feel that white women still demeanour during them by a [white] savior gaze: “Yes, we are all women and feminists, though we are still well-developed women by being white women; we possess improved outcomes and know what’s improved for you.” That’s a atmosphere in that she done her comment.

Based on your possess work in passionate and reproductive health in South Africa, is there any significant basement for Blair’s statement?

What we know for certain is that [when] a lot of immature girls who do go by passionate experiences, contact, invasion mostly for a initial time, even with their possess peers, agree is not entirely understood. So technically what [Blair is] observant is not totally flawed, though it is injured in that there’s no context to it.

What is a context?

Rape is not an African knowledge or a black lady experience. It’s a tellurian experience. By creation it a “black African woman” thing, she’s feeding a classify that we are so disempowered that no matter what we do, we don’t have agency.

So by observant “African,” Blair pragmatic race, not only geography?

People like to use this tenure “African women” to communicate a account of a lady who doesn’t caring adequate about herself. But they don’t indeed meant each lady in Africa. Blair’s not articulate about other white women who demeanour like her, who occur to live in Africa or who grew adult there. She’s articulate about black African girls.

So how would we have favourite to hear Blair speak about a emanate she was perplexing to strew light on?

If she had primarily answered: “In my experience, in a programs I’ve been in and in a conversations I’ve had with women, nonconsensual sex is a problem that keeps entrance up. Even as someone who’s not from Africa, we know it happens,” this would have been a totally opposite positioning of a issue.

It affirms that yes, investigate shows this is a problem, though as an ally, we can’t leave African women feeling ashamed and some-more disempowered by your attitude.


Joanne Lu is a freelance publisher who covers tellurian misery and inequity. Her work has seemed in Humanosphere, The Guardian, Global Washington and War is Boring. Follow her on Twitter: @joannelu

Copyright 2019 NPR. To see more, revisit https://www.npr.org.

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Widgetized Section

Go to Admin » appearance » Widgets » and move a widget into Advertise Widget Zone