Ask Nick: Why do Michigan football fans seem so angry?


Jim Harbaugh discusses a Wolverines’ 2018 recruiting class, and explains a mind-set QBs Brandon Peters, Dylan McCaffrey and Shea Patterson should have going into subsequent season. Recorded Dec. 20, 2017.
Nick Baumgardner, Detroit Free Press

Neither sleet nor sleet nor sleet nor a severe recruiting tighten will delayed a mailbag. 

National signing day is over and copiousness of Michigan fans were, we’ll say, reduction than thrilled. 

All that, and more, in this week’s mailbag. On with a questions.  

Q: How unhappy (maybe unhappy is a improved word) should a fan bottom be if a organisation posts another 8-5 record (in 2018)? The report is not friendly. The underwhelming opening by a O-line, WRs QB positions are long-lived issues. – @GoMBlue21 

A: we had to hang adult a doom and dejection questions somehow. And there were a lot of them. 

I’m not here to tell anyone how to feel. That’s your decision. we can’t suppose another 8-5 debate would go over well. Same time, I’m not certain what to consider when it comes to angry Michigan fans these days. 

More: Michigan’s severe recruiting day a sign of Jim Harbaugh’s reality

I wrote about this right around a time Brady Hoke was fired, when no one was utterly certain if Jim Harbaugh was going to take this job. The expectations here are insane. They’re because this is, in my opinion, one of a toughest jobs in America. And I’m not certain where they came from. 

I’m not vocalization in absolutes here, of course, as there’s a poignant apportionment of this fan bottom that lives in reality. But there’s a separate, also significant, apportionment that appears to trust a customary here is some form of soundness that’s never unequivocally been achieved. 

More: Michigan football’s OT Grant Newsome still carefree for 2018 return

Coaches and teams are judged by measures determined in a 70s and 80s, when college football was a informal oddity and not a inhabitant phenomenon. There’s usually been one ideal deteriorate here given 1949 — nonetheless anything brief of soundness seems to be nit-picked and unsuitable to a organisation who found themselves raging this week when Michigan was incompetent to follow an underwhelming deteriorate with a rarely ranked recruiting class. 

So, we don’t know how fans are ostensible to feel or think. But a prevalent idea we get from many is flattering clear. One I’ve overwhelmed on before. 

If this doesn’t work with Harbaugh, will it ever work? 

That’s it right there. That’s where, in my opinion, fan angst comes from. Michigan fans pined for a savior and many suspicion that would be Harbaugh. It’s usually been 3 years, maybe he’s a answer. But, they’re seeking themselves, what if he’s not? What if this whole thing turns into Tennessee? 

All we can contend is this: The Michigan pursuit is unequivocally tough. It wasn’t easy before Harbaugh got here and it’s not easy now. No matter what happens in 2018, we don’t see that fact changing. 

Q: What are we many astounded about per a Harbaugh reign so far? – @arhopp 

A: we can’t remember a accurate date, though we know it was during Harbaugh’s initial deteriorate and one of a initial media sessions with him. Someone asked a doubt about a descent line and his answer always stranded with me. 

The run diversion and restraint schemes in ubiquitous were a many formidable to implement. They, he said, took a longest to stick. When it finally hits, you’ll know it. You’ll feel it. You’ll see it. 

It’s been 3 full seasons. And while Michigan’s had some engaging resources with a descent line room, a fact it’s still not operative a approach it should be stands out above all else. 

Most infrequent observers still indicate to a quarterback. On some level, that’s fair. we indicate to a descent line. 

Michigan’s inability to contest adult front opposite top-level foe is still a biggest barrier station between this organisation and a championship-level season. For all a faults and flaws Michigan’s offense had final season, and there were several, if that descent line was above normal we wouldn’t have watched an 8-5 season. You wouldn’t have sent dual starting quarterbacks to a hospital, we would’ve had something petrify to rest on and something that would’ve positively complimented a stellar defense. 

If we can run a football and strengthen your quarterback, you’re forward of a curve. Michigan, when a chips have been down, has been means to do conjunction during Harbaugh’s initial 3 years. 

Plenty of folks are now pinning all their hopes on a eligibility of Shea Patterson in 2018. If Patterson’s authorised and personification good football behind an descent line that can’t protect, it won’t matter. 

I’ve gotten copiousness of questions about run-pass choice and descent tweaks. None of it matters if we can’t retard people. Go watch a Super Bowl again. Philadelphia’s RPO sets accomplish zero if a interior of that descent line isn’t dominating. 

Fix a descent line, repair yourself. 

It’s elementary adequate to work. 

QWho’s a actor in this category we’ll be looking behind and observant “how was he rated that low?” – @ZackVanek

A: I’ve left behind and onward on this one. Ben VanSumeren, a parsimonious end/H-back/fullback from Essexville Garber comes to mind. Michael Barrett, a versatile descent arms from Georgia is another. 

But I’m going to go with 3-star dilemma Gemon Green. A 6-foot-2, 175-pounder from Texas who can play any mark in a defensive backfield, Green’s shutting speed and altogether athleticism jumped off a shade when we watched his film. 

He and his twin brother, German, committed really early when his offer list wasn’t all that impressive. But he seems to be a actor and one that could surpass in a accumulation of opposite spots in Don Brown’s defense. 

It’s easy to see because Michigan took him early and hung on via a recruiting cycle. 

QWho is going to step adult and be this year’s Derrick Walton in a final month of a deteriorate going into a Tournament? Or does this organisation not have that person? – @tomgeyer 

A: There’s no comparison indicate ensure on this team, so we doubt you’ll see something like that. Still, I’m not certain Michigan needs some arrange of drastic particular bid to pull itself toward a ceiling. 

The small things have condemned this organisation of late. Free throws. The ability to adjust a offense to opposite defensive looks. Knocking down open shots. Converting a easy stuff.

This is a best defensive team, statistically, John Beilein’s had by 26 games. But a offense still has to govern during a high level. 

Getting some-more fit descent play from Charles Matthews each night would be a start. If he can spin a corner, all changes. People concentration copiousness on Zavier Simpson’s flaws as a sophomore indicate guard, and that’s fine. 

But Matthews, to me, could be a answer. 

Contact Nick Baumgardner: Follow him on Twitter:  @nickbaumgardner.

Download a Wolverines Xtra app for giveaway on Apple and Android devices!


You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Widgetized Section

Go to Admin » appearance » Widgets » and move a widget into Advertise Widget Zone